Ultimately it depends what each of us wants from our holiday, for me
Icmeler ticks all the boxes .
14-17 days to spend with my wife and children without work and business travel butting in. - YES
Guaranteed Weather - YES
Peace and Quiet (We stay in the old village) - YES
Good Choice of restaurants - YES
Good Food - YES
Good Service - YES
Good value for money - YES
Friendly people - YES
Safe environment - YES
A Selection of Trips (peacful and wild) - YES
Local History - YES
we don't go for the entertainment and normally leave places that have entertainment after out meal anyway and go somewhere for a quiet drink for good conversation.
In defence of Redroz I have been somewhere before and had a great time the first time but didn't enjoy it as much the second time, also I think a one or two of the replies on here are un-called for and could be seen as insulting which have only forced redroz onto the defensive.
This forum is normally very friendly and helpful, lets keep it that way.
Dave