We have been to
Icmeler 14 times and having done all of the 'boat trips' some ok some terrible and the usual Dalyan, booze trips etc. Last year we finally decided to rent out a boat just for us (3 adults and 3 kids). A quick wander around the Marina I spotted a huge 'gin palace' but they would not rent for the day (to Brits anyway

).A little further on was a nice wooden gullett type which was rented for £100 - this included lunch and three bottles of reasonably tasting red / white wine as well as the usual efes and soft drinks for the kids.
All aboard at 0930. 1st stop a quiet bay until a huge tourist boat came chugging in - time to go said the captain so we went to another quiet bay and so on. Lunch was chicken in a light spicy sauce with dill and rice, even the kids liked it!!!!!! melon for the adults and ice creams for the kids nothing was too much for the captain he even left us on the boat for an hour whilst he went swimming. We returned to
Marmaris marina at 1830. It was so good we booked again for the following week. 3 adults 3 children (happy) efes, good food, sun it was pimms o'clock at 3pm.
On the 2nd trip with this captain we went to a bay where, in all of my years of going to Icmeler, I have never seen so many fish and other wildlife. The captain did not put down the anchor here but tied up as not to disturb the bottom. So one can only assume it was some sort of reserve as pointed out later. He said that the big boats are not allowed in there.
I have also scuba dived many times and would always book a small boat as some of the bigger ones seem not to give you long in the water. Done some superb wall dives and have even been taken into an underwater cave..... very dark but the light at the end shining on the surface when we came up was something I shall always remember (and I'm not qualified but did know the dive instructor).
If we go back (alas not this year) we will seek out the same boat and go again, it made our holiday.
Fatblokecaver