Apartment help & Hello!!

I'm new to the forum so it's only polite if I say Hello to everyone first
I was recommended to the forum by someone on Tripadvisor as the Icmeler forum on there seems a little slow. I'm hoping you guys will be able to give me lots of advice as I've never been to Icmeler before (only been to Olu Deniz).
I'm having trouble deciding which apartments to book, there seem to be so many with conflicting reviews.
We're after somewhere within a short walk of the beach and centre. Don't mind if it's an apartment or a hotel. We'd prefer 3 star or higher. We don't usually spend much time in the apartments as we're beach people so it'll be just somewhere to sleep and get showered really and we'll be going in September.
The places we've been looking at so far are Efes Inn, Golmar, Gondal, Babadan and Mitos. Just when we think we've found the perfect place we read something that puts us off. Help!!
Looking forward to any advice you can give me.

I'm having trouble deciding which apartments to book, there seem to be so many with conflicting reviews.
We're after somewhere within a short walk of the beach and centre. Don't mind if it's an apartment or a hotel. We'd prefer 3 star or higher. We don't usually spend much time in the apartments as we're beach people so it'll be just somewhere to sleep and get showered really and we'll be going in September.
The places we've been looking at so far are Efes Inn, Golmar, Gondal, Babadan and Mitos. Just when we think we've found the perfect place we read something that puts us off. Help!!
Looking forward to any advice you can give me.