Yes, we have strayed from
Icmeler quite a few times, but have not found anywhere that betters (or matches it even) in any way. Sept/Oct will be our 16th visit - so I guess we have definitely got the "bug".
Last June we decided we would try a different resort in Turkey and went to Hisaronu. The place is absolutely gorgeous - beautiful scenery, great hotel. lovely town and good food etc., The only problem was - IT WASN'T ICMELER. So after 3 days of thinking that we were so close, yet so far away and being utterly miserable, we decided to pack our cases, catch a taxi, and head "back home" to Icmeler. It cost us £80 for the taxi, £170 for another
Hotel and £40 for a taxi back to the airport, but it was worth every penny and we had a great time. Then we returned again in September for a Turkish/English wedding which was amazing.
Again, not learning from our mistakes, we went to Cuba this March - nice place, nice people etc but very boring and not Icmeler. So we have to wait months now for a great holiday !!!